Whose Story is it Anyway?

« Back to Blog Home
by John Rich | posted in , ,
12/17/2009

I attended a small book launch event here in Philly for my book Wrong Place, Wrong Time: Trauma and Violence in the Lives of Young Black Men. The book tells the stories of young patients who were shot or stabbed who I met when I was a practicing as a doctor at Boston City Hospital. Roy, a young man and former gangster who is profiled in the book for his generous efforts to help me understand the streets, came down from Boston to join us. The event was held in the Pyramid Club, a lavish but tasteful setting on the 52nd floor of the Mellon Bank Building on Market Street in downtown Philadelphia.

I spent a few minutes telling the guests why I wrote the book and what the stories meant to me. I emphasized that the stories of these young men needed to be told and needed to be heard. These are human beings who are so often treated like they are not. When they are blamed for the horrible violence that has befallen them, it traumatizes them further.

I introduced Roy and he sauntered to the microphone with an air of humility. He talked about how our friendship had helped him and how the fact that I was not “gangsta” helped him to see a different set of possibilities in the world. But what most struck me was when Roy turned to me and said “This is your story too. You might be talking about the lives of other young guys, but you have a right to tell your story the way you want to tell it. And I am cool with that.”

I thought about it a lot even as the evening wound down and the mini crab cake appetizers got munched away. There really is no way to tell someone else’s story without also telling our own. We cannot channel these young men without channeling ourselves as well. It is a shared story, and because of this, we also share the responsibility for making things change.

Roy got it right tonight. But, then again, he usually does.

 

Comments
By Lisa at 2009/12/20 20:52

I have a front row view of the daily violence these young men experience. for instance, young men who leave school early to walk home so they do not encounter another group of young men and have to fight their way to their destination. This was a prelude to a school shooting, in which I witnessed the young man take his last breath. Has healing occured? I would say no, because the only conversation, which transpires is retaliation and the cycle continues. There is a neighborhood, which continues to be underserved and the young men have similar stories to the one mentioned. Most are good people they just do not have the necessary resources to help them. I have attempted to direct them to people or centers assist; however, the initial step seems to be difficult. I want to do more, but I feel like I am at an impasse.

By Lonte at 2009/12/30 12:10

There is some comfort, knowing that the affects of PTSD as it relates to brain function and learning can somehow be healed to a certain extent.
Thank you for sharing your personal experiences and providing a voice for young Black men that may have not had the chance to share their stories. I, like the previous reader, see the frustration of young Black men that struggle everyday for some of the simple things that I often take for granted. The day-to-day struggle to survive violence within neighborhood basically creates tension in the air, resentment and clearly perpetuates a level of hostility.
I understand the role and responsibility of good parenting and accountability for one's own actions, as a necessary component to combat the issue.
But even with good child rearing in place, we are not really giving the kids the proper tools necessary to succeed. I agree with the other readers that there has to be a multifaceted approach to this issue by creating environments that nurture.
It's disheartening to see the rapid deterioration of our inner city's educational systems that as a result we continue to see an alarming rise in the United States high school drop out rate.
I understand that there must be multifaceted approach to improve the situation.
I see that we recognize that inner city youth violence is an issue that needs to be addressed but then on the flipside the sad thing is I don't believe that enough people actually care or view this as an urgent issue (perhaps seen as an important issue of concern but certainly not an urgent one).
The author of the Sanctuary Model makes an excellent point, that in order to gain one must be willing to go through challenging and possibly painful ordeals in order to attain goals. So how can we take this concept and put it to action on a larger scale, especially if urban youth (especially those of color) are not typically valued by society anyway.
Inner city kids (or just youth in general) need tangible real-life examples of positivity.
And to Lisa, I also at times feel hopeless at times as well but do not be deterred by overwhelming circumstances or throw in the towel either. I realize that this issue is not about me, it's about what I will do to help.
Great inspiration and conversation!

Thanks for sharing.
I look forward to reading your book as well! Congrats…
"The journey of a thousand miles begins with one single step" Lao-Tzu
Lonte Jacobs Executive MPH Student 2011


Self Esteem and health
By Ramon at 2010/01/02 09:24

I just read an interesting article by Michael Marmot, titled "Self esteem and health: autonomy, self esteem, and health are linked together" (BMJ, September 2003)

This article was well written and brings up a solid point: violence stems from having to prove something.

His hypothesis is "that unequal distribution of resources leads to increased competition for status among young men who have little to lose other than their self esteem and the respect of others." This creates tension between the "haves" and "have nots" which intensify when disrespect and pride get in the way of respectful and constructive dialogue and civil interaction. "Where inequality is high people at the bottom of the scale may express their response to threats to their self esteem in violent ways."

Self Esteem and Identity
By John at 2010/01/08 08:14

Marmot's editorial and the book he cites are powerful. I wonder about how the concepts of self esteem and identity connect here. Self esteem reflects how you feel about yourself and this is important. In my mind, identify reflects the essence of who you are and your value in the community. Subtle differences, but I see young men using violence to make an identity for themselves - to be "somebody" - even if the identify is a notorious one. Makes me wonder if by creating new and positive ways to be somebody, we might open a new horizon for their futures.

A Whole New Perspective
By Maureen at 2010/05/18 17:30

Thank you for your wonderfully written and enlightening book. I have been looking for an explanation and a rationale for the so called “gangsta/gangbanger” lifestyle, because I am a firm believer in the notion that human beings are inherently good. This book clarifies a lot for me, and opens up a whole new perspective that I had not thought about. More so, it increases that urgency in me to want to be a part of the solution. However, like some people above, I feel hopeless, especially by the fact that I do not even know where to begin. If any of you that are reading this have suggestions, please point me in the right direction. Maureen, MPH student.

Add a comment:

We encourage you to leave comments to postings. However, inappropriate comments will be deleted by a Center moderator.

 
Created by NetReach. ® Powered by Content Management System (CMS)